In calculus today, I went off the beaten path a bit and it was a lovely digression. I think this works so well with my kids not only because they’re awesome, but because quite a few of them like to notice patterns and explore.
So far we’ve learned and proved the power rule for derivatives, and we’ve been practicing using it. So if students are given and asked to find , they know that they have to distribute and then take the derivative. [We don’t know the product rule yet.]
So… for their work due today, they were asked to find the derivative of . And my kids wanted to go over this together in class. So when we worked it all out, we got . And then someone noticed that was the same as which looked like the power rule! Like if we had , the derivative would be , so similarly since we have , it’s makes sense that the derivative was .
At this point, I decided I wanted to capitalize on this. So I said: okay, neat observation. Does it always hold?
And I threw this up…
And then they checked…
… and saw it was wrong. So based on this, I had them revise their conjecture, and take a stab at:
which they did… and they came up with (and worked out):
So they believed they had something that always worked… so I had them prove it. Which they did.
And it worked out!!!
So now we had proved something about the derivative of , and I asked them: would it work to the third power? would it work to the nth power? And I left it as an exercise for their home enjoyment (our corny term for homework). I’m really curious to see who gets how far on this!
It’s cool. They’re getting whiffs of the chain rule. I’m not going to give it to ’em or do anything else with this. We’ll wait a while. But I really like how this digression took 15 minutes, but it capitalized on something they were curious about. And we’ll see the connection later.
I felt strongly enough about how this worked out that I engineered this discussion to happen in my second calculus class. I treated it like a big surprise. What a strange observation. Instead of forging forward in class, let’s take a digression. I loved that it worked a second time too.