In Geometry, we’re about to embark on the whole triangle congruence bit (SSS, SAS, ASA, etc.). Below is the plan we have outlined.
The TL;DR version: By learning about angle bisectors, we motivate the need for triangle congruence. We have students figure out when they have enough information to show two triangles are congruent. They use this newfound knowledge of triangle congruence to prove basic things they know are true about quadrilaterals, but have yet to prove that they are true. Finally, we return back to angle bisectors, and show that for any triangle, the three angle bisectors always meet at a point. As a cherry on the top of the cake, we do an activity involving salt to illustrate this point.
STEP 1: To motivate the need to figure out when we can say two triangles are congruent when we have limited information, we are showing a problem where triangle congruence is necessary to make an obvious conclusion.
We’re going to see the need for triangle congruence to show that:
any point that is equidistant to an angle (more precisely: the two rays that form an angle) lies on the angle bisector of that angle.
This will be an obvious fact for students once they create a few examples. But when they try to prove it deductively, they’ll hit a snag. They’ll get to the figure on the left, below. But in order to show the congruent angles, they’ll really want to say “the two triangles are congruent.” But they don’t have any rationale to make that conclusion.
Hence: our investigation in what we need in order to conclude two triangles are congruent.
When kids do this, they will also be asked to draw a bunch of circles tangent to the angles. All these centers are on the angle bisector of the angle. This will come up again at the end of our unit.
Kids will be doing all of this introductory material on this packet (.docx)
STEP 2: Students discover what is necessary to state triangle congruence.
This is a pretty traditional introduction to triangle congruence. Students have to figure out if they can draw only one triangle with given information — or multiple triangles.
We’re going to pull this together as a class, and talk about why ASA and SAS and SSS must yield triangle congruence — and we’ll do this when we talk about how we construct these triangles. When you have ASA, SAS, SSS, you are forced to have only a single triangle.
I anticipate drawing the triangles in groups, and pulling all this information together as a class, is going to be conversation rich.
The pages we’re going to be using are below (.docx) [slight error: in #4, the triangle has lengths of 5 cms, 6 cms, and 7 cms]
STEP 3: Once we have triangle congruence, we’re going to use triangle congruence to prove all sorts of properties of quadrilaterals.
Specifically, they are going to draw in diagonals in various quadrilaterals, which will create lots of different congruent triangles. From this, they will be asked to determine:
(a) Can they say anything about the relationship between one diagonal and the other diagonal (e.g. the diagonals bisect each other; the diagonals always meet at right angles)
(b) Can they say anything about the relationship between the diagonals and the quadrilateral (e.g. one diagonal bisects the two angles)
(c) Can they conclude anything about the quadrilateral itself (e.g. the opposite sides are congruent; opposite angles are congruent)
We have a few ideas percolating about how to have students investigate and present their findings, but nothing ready to share yet. The best idea we have right now is to have students use color to illustrate their conclusions visually, like this:
STEP 4: This is a throwback to the very start of the unit. Students will prove that in any triangle, the angle bisectors will always meet at a single point.
Here are the guiding questions (.docx)
And we will finish this off by highlighting the circles we drew at the start of the unit. Notice we have a single circle that is tangent to all three sides of the triangle. The center of that circle? Where the angle bisectors meet. Why? You just proved it! That location is equidistant to all three sides of the triangle.
STEP 5: The reason we’re highlighting these circles is that we’re going to be cutting out various triangles (and other geometric shapes) out of cardboard, elevate them, and then pour salt on them. Ridges will form. These ridges will be angle bisectors. Why? Because each time you pour salt on something flat, it forms a cone. The top of the cone will the the center of the circle. We’re just superimposing a whole bunch of salt cones together to form the ridges.
The other geometry teacher and I both saw this salt activity at the Exeter conference years ago. Here are some images from a short paper from Troy Stein (who is awesome) on this:
The general idea for this activity is going to be: kids take a guess as to where the ridges are going to be, kids pour the salt and see where the ridges are.
As the figures get more complex, they should start thinking more deeply. For example, in the quadrilateral figure above, why do you get that long ridge in the middle?
My hope is that they start to visualize the figures that they are pouring salt on as filled with little cones, like this:
The material I’ve whipped up for this is here (.docx):
Wow! This is an amazing unit! This is a great example of a series of activities in which students are gently guided towards developing several important geometrical truths that historically have been simply given to them and expected to be memorized, not questioned. (SAS, SSS, ASA, angle bisectors being equidistant from the sides, inscribed circles, incenters, circumcenters, etc.)
Your unit is designed like a novel with twists and turns in the plot. You introduce characters that are seemingly unrelated (at the beginning, I was wondering: Where does salt come it?)
What a breath of fresh air compared to the the normal dry lessons in which students are told SAS, SSS, ASA, asked to memorize them, perhaps asked why ASS doesn’t work (because we can’t say “ASS” in school, of course!)
Thank you for sharing this wonderful unit. Within the past month, I ran across an email from some math organization offering $$ for units. If I can find it again, I’ll email it to you.
Keep up the awesome work!
You, my friend, are awesome for posting this. I was hoping someone would see it, and then I was secretly hoping they would like it, and then even more secretly, I was hoping they would tell me.
YOU FULFILLED MY DOUBLE SECRET HOPE!
Thank you, thank you, thank you. Some good news: we’re in the middle of implementing it, and it’s actually going really well thus far. The constructions they’re making are making their understanding of ASA/SSS/SAS/AAS really concrete in the way I was hoping for!
I’m glad that I was able to fulfill your double secret hope! I met you a couple of years ago at TMC 2014 in Philly. I loved your enthusiasm and sense of humor. It’s obvious that you bring that to your classroom as well. Keep up the awesome work and keep sharing it (especially student work ) so that we all can learn from it.